MANITOWOC (NBC 26) — The jury has begun deliberating the fate of Timothy Hauschultz, the Manitowoc County man accused of child abuse and neglect in connection to the death of his 7-year-old great-nephew, Ethan Hauschultz.
Watch the full broadcast here:
Timothy Hauschultz pleaded not guilty to all charges. He faces six counts:
- First count: Neglect of a child, death as a consequence
- Second count: Contributing to the delinquency of a child, death as a consequence
- Third count: Party to a crime, physical abuse of a child, intentional bodily harm to a child
- Fourth count: Contributing to the delinquency of a child, intentional bodily harm
- Fifth count: Physical abuse of a child, intentional bodily harm, party to a crime
- Sixth count: Physical abuse of a child, intentional bodily harm, party to a crime
The case followed five days of testimony and seven days of trial.
In closing statements Tuesday morning, prosecutors argued the punishment Timothy Hauschultz chose for Ethan Hauschultz and his brother was abusive, pointing to the weight of the logs, the length of the punishment and the winter conditions.
"Ethan is 62 lbs and he is carrying a 44 pound log. It's approximately two thirds his weight," Manitowoc County District Attorney Jacalyn Labre said.
"The kids felt they were powerful and these logs were given to them to break them," Labre said.
"They called it forced physical activity or forced physical discipline," Labre said. "In fact between, when Mrs. Kuchler started (with closing statements) and now we still wouldn't have hit the two hours. The kids still would have had 20 minutes to go."
The state also pointed to the testimony of medical experts, who stated the punishments were out of proportion to the infractions.
"Both of them testified that this type of punishment is abusive and causes children pain and injury," Labre said.
"Ethan didn't get the care he needed," Labre said.
But the defense argued the jurors' decision is not about parenting.
"The question here isn't if you agree with Tim's parenting decisions, it's if you think that conduct is criminal," Defense Attorney Donna Kuchler said.
The defense also argued Timothy never told his son, Damian -who has already been convicted in connection to the death - to use physical force, saying Damian took it too far.
"He didn't die because he was required to carry wood," Kuchler said.
The defense pointed to Hauschultz's efforts after he found Ethan.
"First thing is to remove wet clothes, check that's what Tim did. Second is to warm the body, check that's what Tim did. Third is to wrap in a blanket, check that's what Tim did," Kuchler said.
"You can not hold Tim responsible for Damians actions just because he is the adult in the family," Kuchler said.
The defense compared the medical examiner and doctor testimony, pointing out differences. It claimed Ethan was growing well, when the doctor said this punishment could have stunted growth throughout. The defense challenged the state's testimony.
"Don't turn a parents desperate panic rescue to a criminal planned attack," Kuchler said.
"We don't convict someone on speculation," Kuchler said.
NBC26 will stay with this trial until a verdict is reached. You can read the latest from day 6 of the trial here.
This story was reported on-air by a journalist and has been converted to this platform with the assistance of AI. Our editorial team verifies all reporting on all platforms for fairness and accuracy.